The Majlis

Question ID: 20986

Salaams Dear Mufti,
I often read ” THE MAJLIS” and find that the response to certain issues by the writer at THE MAJLIS is filled with insults, sarcasm and trying to belittle certain people, I must point out that i am in no way affiliated to any organisation in any way. My question is would this be the response of our Rasool or would our beloved Nabi try and point out an error or try to explain in a more civil way?

Marked as spam
Asked on February 27, 2014 12:14 am
Private answer

Every Nabi had his method; Hadhrat Moosa (A.S) had his own method, Hadhrat Isa (A.S) had his own method, etc. Every Sahabi (R.A) had his own method; Hadhrat Abu Bakr (R.A) had his own method, Hadhrat Umar (R.A) had his own method, etc. Nabi's reacted differently in different situations as well. Some were firm and some were soft. Expressions differ. We should bear all.

"The addressees of being harsh towards the disbelievers and the hypocrites

O Nabi, strive against the disbelievers and hypocrites and be harsh towards them. Rasulullaah (S.A.W) practised upon the first part of this verse according to its right. However, the second part, i.e. he did the opposite, i.e. he was soft with the hypocrites. Apparently, this seems contrary to the verse.


Harsh against the disbelievers was by means of the sword and against the hypocrites it was with the tongue. Where there was a need for softness, he exercised softness, otherwise he was harsh. Subsequently, Ruh al Maani states that on one Jumuah, Rasulullaah named the hypocrites and removed them from the Masjid. Stand, o you, because indeed you are a hypocrite, stand, o you, because indeed you are a hypocrite. Being soft with the leader of the hypocrites was in order to win the heart of his sons and the sword of character was used to cut the other hypocrites. "

Marked as spam