Muftis giving different answers to the same question

Question ID: 29472

Assalam o alaikum,

Respected Sir, I want to ask that how is that when a particular question is asked from a Mufti of Hanafi fiqh and the same question when asked from another Mufti of Hanafi fiqh both give different answers. Do they study the same hadith and follow the same principles of shariah or different. If it is same then how the answer is different and the practice (amal) is also different. Like Barailwi Mufti and Deoband Mufti.

2. Sometimes the question asked to a mufti who studied in Deoband or at its branch and the same question asked to a different mufti of the same school of thought i.e. either studied in Deoband or at its branch has a different answer, how and why is that. It becomes a litle confusing. Not all the questions has a different answer but some of do has a different answer. Could you please explain and avoid my and other person like me who has the same issue. Thanking You!

Jazzak Allah!

Marked as spam
Asked on March 13, 2014 9:41 pm
Private answer

Each Mufti's ability in understanding is different. Each Mufti's power of comprehension varies. Place your confidence and reliance in one Mufti and follow his rulings. Allaah will aid you.

Marked as spam
Answered on March 13, 2014 9:41 pm