Mufti Menk

Question ID: 30191

Dear mufti, On what grounds does Muft answer that Muft Menk is a Safafi or students studying in Saudi become salafi by default. I know of someone who graduated from Madinah but is really hanafi.. It is extreme to judge someone through association. You are both respected muftis and some of your fatwas seem harsh to the general public and now confusing us.

Perhaps a one to one with mufti Menk would be the best way forward with a conclusion shared to layman to assist our own sanity.


Marked as spam
Asked on August 31, 2013 3:52 pm
Private answer

Historically at one stage unfortunately Madinah University gradates had mostly Salafi inclined teachers as a result most of the graduates were duly influenced.
However, we have been informed that of late (2012/3) there has been some radical changes, we want to see and witness the positive results.
Truth seems harsh and at times bitter. We will alter if valid Shaari proofs are brought. Confusion lies in falsehood.

Marked as spam
Answered on August 31, 2013 3:52 pm