Does fadhail-e-aamaal contains many fabricated (maudhou) ahaadith?

Question ID: 24248

salaam. muhtram mufti sahib, i hope you are well. i read on that you had mentioned that fadhail-e-aamaal contains many fabricated (maudhou) ahaadith. is this true? if it is then which are these ahaadith.
secondly, i also read that you gave a fatwa that dhikr bil jahar in masjid is not jaaiz. please can you enlighten me on this.
jazakallahu kairan.

Marked as spam
Asked on March 7, 2011 12:48 pm
Private answer

1) Glad you are clarifying. I did not say anywhere that Fazail-e-Amal has fabricated Ahadith. The narrator maybe smoking.
2) Our research is that loud congregational Zikr done in unision is the Masjid is not proven in Shariat.
For more details search on site.

Marked as spam
Answered on March 7, 2011 12:48 pm