Question ID: 27810

Q2296 you answering Q2289,

As salaamu alaikum, Jazak’Allah for your answers.
in respect to Q2246 where you answered Q2175,

Point 5, you answered that all commercial meat , irrespective of their ‘Halaal’ status will become ‘Makrooh’ according to Shariah? Is this correct?
That is, meat subjected to scalder process will be Makrooh, and if water is hot enough / too hot it will be Haraam for consumption?

There is medical and scientific studies that prove undoubtedly birds do die from stunning,
if this is accepted as a medical fact,
& considering that this practice of stunning is in vogue in ALL commercial meat production
and in the absence of any equipment to verify and accurately separate & remove the carrion,
Will the meat remain halaal, haraam or makrooh on account of a unknown number of carrion mixed in inevitably , or what is the Shari Ruling & Directive regarding this type of produce ?

The Jamiat KZN has been denied unfettered access to Rainbow, as they are a Religious Authority, not a profit driven organisation,
How do we interpret this in terms of Shariah ?

Marked as spam
Asked on December 9, 2008 12:00 am
Private answer

1) Yes
2) Makrooh
3) The Jamiat KZN should take this matter up seriously if they have the 'clout' to do so
Marked as spam
Answered on December 9, 2008 12:00 am