Thoughts of kufr with no intention of kufr

Question ID: 29767

Aslaam alaikum

Dear muft sahib
. I have a question regarding faith. If a muslim thinks in the head or says in the mind that ‘Muhammad (S.A.W) was not all that or was crap’ (astaghfirullah) Does this make them a non Muslim?
This was in the mind without any intention of Kufr. And as these Thoughts were running in the mind, the Muslim still fully loved Islam and the prophet Muhammad (S.A.W)

As these thoughts were in the mind the Muslim fully believes and loves the prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) and has no intention to utter these thoughts.
Does these thoughts make him a non Muslim?


Marked as spam
Asked on January 10, 2014 2:00 pm
Private answer

Laws are not upon thoughts. However, these sort of thoughts are super dangerous. Seek spiritual guidance and aid. Protect your Imaan. Putting these thoughts into words (i.e. saying them) is pure kufr.

Marked as spam
Answered on January 10, 2014 2:00 pm