Salaams. If a husband tells his wife the fatwa for question ID:31756,which states its kufr.
The husband says to his wife that he has heard her use the word atma/soul and has heard her saying that the atma/soul comes back to Earth to do things&things as explained in the question ID 31756 e.g. to wonder around Earth, visit families and complete unfinished business,take revenge against people that have killed them, come back because they died or got killed because they didn’t get married to their true love etc.
The wife verbally replies to her husband and says that she is not sure if it is true whether a persons soul comes back to wander Earth, visit families and complete unfinished business,take revenge against people that have killed them, come back because they died or got killed because they didn’t get married to their true love etc. AND she has heard people say that the soul comes back to Earth to do the above things mentioned and she doesn’t know if this is true or false.
The wife also says that in the past she has thought about whether the atma/soul returns to Earth to do things. Mentioned above and the things mentioned in Question ID: 31756, and whether this might be true.
1)Does the wife become kafir by any of her above explanations or any of the above answers and replies from the wife?
2) Does the wife become a kafir if due to lack of Islamic knowledge or ignorance she has in the past thought,verbally said or maybe believed that the soul does and can come back Earth to wander &do things mentioned in Question ID:31756?