Massallah pertaining to Talaaq

Question ID: 24699

Salaam Mufti
My question is regarding Talaq.
What is the ruling regarding if my brother has given his wife three Talaq’s in one sitting but they have not seperated as they consulted some Moulana that said that, he said 3 Talaq’s in anger therefore the 3 talaqs are not valid. They consulted the Jamiat and they gave the ruling that the marriage is over but still they went and looked for the answer they required so that they could stay married.
What is the ruling regarding Moulanas that spread such nonsense amongst our muslims will the sinn of staying together fall on the Moulana or will it fall on my brother and his wife for commiting Zinna. The Moulana says they do not have to worry as if he is incorrect then he will get punished not them so they must follow what he says.

Marked as spam
Asked on October 10, 2010 12:00 am
Private answer

Sin on both, the Moulana and the couple.
Ask the Moulana for proofs for his decision.

Marked as spam
Answered on October 10, 2010 12:00 am