Question ID: 24738

who were you atacking.
To day in Jumua Mufti spoke about qurban & the benefits & on whom its wajib. you then also gave answers of the pious scholars of deoband to questions from hindus in india trying to belittle islam. mufti spoke about ikhtilaaf about using buffalo & cow & then he went on about the number of shares a camel holds since a hadith in tirmedhi mentions 10 & then after another which mentions 7. you said the opinion of 10 is wrong because Imaam timidhi said that 7 is what is practiced upon. He then said that the 10 is abrogated by the 7. which school practices on this 7 why can you a hanafi tell them they wrong if they applied their own usool.
then your next words were- just as that is abrogated so is are all the hadith about Raful yaday, amin bi jahr, reading fatihah after the imam, & basmala.
Who is this mufti attacking. are you against all the madhabs exept your own. im sure Imaam Shafi Ra a great scholar of hadith maybe the greates as far as the science goes since the science to great turns after him would have known that these are abrogated . all the shafi muhaditheen; you know the scholars of the sittah. imaam Nawawi who is the interlectual heir to the thrown of Imaam Shafi. so they all wrong & you right.

Marked as spam
Asked on December 10, 2010 12:00 am
Private answer
Do not misunderstand me. I am a Hanafi Muslim. I am a Muqalid. A non-Muqalid is NOT from the Ahlus Sunnat wal Jamaat. We love, respect, honour and defend all Imaams of Fiqh.
See on site our writing on Taqleed and on the life and works on the 4 Illustrious Imaams of Fiqh.
After reading the above you will Insha-Allaah understand.
All 4 Mazhabs say 7 shares in a big animal NOT 10. As the Ahle Hadith sect claim.
Marked as spam
Answered on December 10, 2010 12:00 am