Question ID: 19951
0
0

A modernist Muslim man utters a vile statement of kufr in a small gathering. His relative, Zaid, is enraged, and pulls out a gun, and shoots the murtad multiple times in the chest. While shooting, Zaid shouts: “Then go to Jahannam you stupid kaafir!” The murtad died after a few moments with many bullet wounds in the chest.

Zaid says he was utterly enraged and reacted instinctively by dispatching the murtad to Jahannum. Zaid said he felt this most appropriate and the statement of kufr intolerable. They are not in a Dar al-Islam.

Please comment on the action of Zaid.

Marked as spam
Asked on May 14, 2016 8:50 pm
86 views
0
Private answer

He will be judged as per his intentions. He should not have taken the law in his own hands.

Marked as spam
Answered on May 24, 2016 4:34 pm