Tags:
Question ID: 30764
0
0

Assalamualaikum,Mufti saheb.I would like to know the truth and Islamic status of the views of an Alim who calls himself Sunni,Hanafi and Deobandi.I expect separate answer for each view.These are his views quoted from his talks:1)The Imams of Haramain also do Masah on socks.2)Had Imam-e-Azam(rah) been alive,he would have retracted on the Masail of Haj.2)There is difference of everybody in the principles of Fiqh,because this is purely a thing of Ijtihad.Ahlus Sunnah wal Jamat are one thing.Further,everyone has his own preferences.There are different forms of practices.Ibn Taimiyyah is the first person who called triple Talaq one.Ibn Qayyim endorsed it.Now since both of them are amongst the predecessors of Ghair Muqallideen,so somewhere they accept one’s and somewhere other’s.Our state is also same that somewhere we accept Imam Abu Yusuf’s,somewhere Abu Hanifa(rah)’s.3)If they consider triple Talaq single and after that they return,it is right according to them.It is not right according to us.You(Ahnaf) also ruin house deeming the forced one(Talaq Mukarrah) permissible,whereas you do not have any proof of forced Talaq.Do not force your Fatwas on them nor act on their Fatwas.There will be weak and sound narrations in every Mazhab.

Marked as spam
Asked on November 16, 2012 11:52 am
24 views
0
Private answer
1) On what type of socks? They are not 'Hujjat' (proofs) in Shariat
2) Which Masaail? Why? - Does he think Imam Abu Hanifa (R.A.) is a non-competent person.
Compare likes to likes not otherwise. Separate the wood from the trees is not difficult but not for this person.
3) See on site on 3 Talaaq issue. 3 Talaaqs is equal to one is not valid.
Marked as spam
Answered on November 16, 2012 11:52 am