« Back to Previous Page
Question ID: 30768

Assalamualaikum,Mufti saheb.I would like to know the truth and Islamic status of the views of an Alim who calls himself Sunni,Hanafi & Deobandi.I have already sent two questions regarding Aqaid and Tarikh.I expect answer of each view separately.These are his views quoted from his talks:1)Work is done on negative aspect in madrasas.2)All(Islamic) movements of the past hundred years failed.3)Debates are waste.4)Madrasas have been ruined because of clash between Qadri,Naqshbandi sects.5)The environment of madrasas is based on fanaticism.6)Negative mode of education prevails in madrasas.7)The share for the Qur’an and Hadith is less in our pattern of teaching.8)Let all the sects remain in Islam.9)Moulana Sarfaraz Khan saheb is crown of our head,but he has written all his life on negative aspect.Extremism takes birth in pen by keeping on writing on negative aspect.In his books is refutation of Barelviat,refutation of Rafziat,refutation of Ghair Muqallidiat;refutation,refutation,refutation.He has spent all his life in refutation.So one who keeps on refuting,extremism creeps in his view.10)Moulana(Ameen) Safdar saheb(rah) who would refute Ahle Hadith from us;there was very much harshness in his style,and there was too much intensity.I had sit with him for 4 hours.I had gone to him to benefit.On that,whatever he said,he kept saying.I had been listening.

Marked as spam
Asked on November 16, 2012 6:16 pm
Private answer
1) I studied in Deoband, very little or next to nothing was mentioned about deviates.
2) We require details of this sweeping statement.
3) What about the debates between Hadhrat Ebrahim and Nimrooz and Hadhrat Moosa and Firoun and Nabi (S.A.W) and the Kufaar and Mushriks. This person is silly.
4) Kindly supply proofs.
5) Supply proofs
6) as (5)
7) ?Nonsense - which Darul Uloom has this person studied in?
8) Define 'sects'.
9) His great services cannot be forgotten. His Tafseer is famous. His 'refutations' have salvaged millions. What exactly has the objector done for the service of Deen in any field?
10) Another Pillar of Islaam. Again, show us what you the objector has achieved?
This person is highly confused between Shiasism and Maududism and is making a wrong claim of being from the Ahlus Sunnat wal Jamaat. Stay far from him.
Marked as spam
Answered on November 16, 2012 6:16 pm
« Back to Previous Page