Question ID: 28776

I want to know about a certain hadith in fazail e amaal which advocates loud congregational zikr. It is on page 115, hadith no6, virtues of zikr
– It mentions the prophet (S.A.W) and some sahaba sitting in a room and closing the door and making loud congregational zikr-reported by Ahmed and Darqutni.
Is it authentic?

Marked as spam
Asked on April 24, 2008 12:00 am
Private answer
Although there is no 'Kalam' on the hadith, our claim is : a.) to invite for and b.) engage in :
1.) load zikr;
2.) congregationally done;
3.) in the Masjid. was not done in the time of Nabi (S.A.W) and cannot be proven by Shari proofs.
Marked as spam
Answered on April 24, 2008 12:00 am